Introduction1 the evidence of fine tuning suppose we went on a mission to mars, and found a domed structure in which everything was set up just right for life to exist. The finetuned universe is the proposition that the conditions that allo. More often than as an inference to the best explanation the argument from fine tuning for the multiverse is formulated using probabilities, in analogy to the argument from fine tuning for design see section 3. Confused because since when does the bible go with the big bang theory and what. Critics of the finetuning argument, however, have challenged both.
According to philosopher nicholas everitt, the enormous scale of the universe is inconsistent with the purposes of god as described in classical theism, and therefore is evidence that the god of classical theism does not exist. In view of this, some have taken the opportunity to revive the scholastic argument from design, whereas others have felt the need to explain this apparent finetuning of the clockwork of the. For a recent discussion of some complications, see aguirre 2001. This is a draft of a chapter to appear in the book on the finetuning argument, tentatively entitled the welltempered universe. The fine tuning argument klaas landsman may 20, 2015 abstract our laws of nature and our cosmos appear to be delicately netuned for life to emerge, in way that seems hard to attribute to chance. The fine tuning argument revisited 2000 theodore m. Below is the core of his argument, taken from a shortened article he has made available. Two fatal problems with the fine tuning argument 2015 ryan stringer i.
There are many examples of finetuning of physical constants physics is loaded with them. The fine tuning argument fta is a variant of the design argument for the existence of god. Even if that argument is cogent, it doesnt prove that god exists or that belief in god is justified. The problem for this argument came not from a philosopher finding a flaw in paleys argument, but rather from darwins development of the theory of evolution. In view of this, some have taken the opportunity to revive the scholastic argument from design, whereas others have. In this paper the evidence of fine tuning is explained and the fine tuning design argument for god is presented. Pdf a new finetuning argument for the multiverse researchgate. In view of this, some have taken the opportunity to revive the scholastic argument from design, whereas others have felt the need to explain this apparent fine tuning of the clockwork of the. The first objection is that finetuning can be explained in terms of. The many problems of the finetuning argument by francois tremblay.
Mar 20, 2019 the old argument from fine tuning for the multiverse is usually presented in bayesian terms, using subjective probability assignments. This was shown through my parody divinepruning argument. An exploration of the finetuning of the universe robin collins 1. The earth having precisely the right characteristics to support human life. The finetuning argument intends to establish a finetuner god since something so specific as a human being arising by random cosmic chance is too improbable to believe.
What do you think of the finetuning argument for god. The fine tuning argument intends to establish a fine tuner god since something so specific as a human being arising by random cosmic chance is too improbable to believe. The many problems of the fine tuning argument by francois tremblay. Probabilities and the finetuning argu oxford academic journals. According to carl sagan, the universe cosmos is all that is or ever was or ever will be. This cosmological constant is a force that increases with the increasing size of the universe. This is a very good question, martin, about which id like to think more. There are various misgivings about the finetuning argument which are based on misunderstandings. Fine tuning in cosmology 1 a good overview of the case for fine tuning can be found in chapter 2 of leslie 1989. The finetuning argument purports to show that particular aspects of fundamental physics provide evidence for the existence of god. Fine tuning and physical necessity fine tuning argument design from finetuning probability of finetuning fine tuned universe finely tuned universe is the argument from finetuning presumptuous. But such fine tuning, in order to make life possible, requires a fine tuner. In this paper the evidence of finetuning is explained and the finetuning design argument for god is presented. Confused because since when does the bible go with the big bang theory and what was collins saying in that case.
In this paper the evidence of fine tuning is explained and the fine tuning design argument for god is. The main advantage of the new argument is that it is not susceptible to the inverse gamblers fallacy charge. His training is in physics and in philosophy and he is a leading advocate for using the finetuning of the universe as a design argument for theism. The human race evolving to be precisely the way it is. We know we won the lottery, but we dont know how many tickets we bought. The finetuning argument fta is a variant of the design argument for the existence of god. Recent studies have confirmed the fine tuning of the cosmological constant also known as dark energy.
The first is that there is an internal conflict between the arguments premises and its conclusionnamely, that if the premises hold, then the conclusion does not. This chapter should give the basic idea of my approach to defining the comparison range, and my response to. A careful inspection of the values of the different parameters. In this article, i propose that, in addition to the multiverse hypothesis, which is commonly taken to be an alternative explanation for fine tuning, other than the design hypothesis, the simulation hypothesis is another explanation for fine tuning. I have here argued that there are two fatal problems with the finetuning argument. Some theists think that scientific findings provide evidence for gods existence. Mar 01, 20 the fine tuning argument poses what seems to be another tough obstacle for the atheist. Tuning argument fta is a variant of the design argument for the existence of god. Drange this article was originally published in philo 2000 vol. To briefly summarize, creationists argue that there is a vanishingly small probability of. Chapter 2 finetuning in cosmology anthropic principle. Fine tuning is a subset of the anthropic principle, the idea that the universe is somehow biased in favor of life bearing. The first such example of a god argument is that of fine tuning. If the universe is wonderfully designed, surely god is even more wonderfully.
This would have to be some being with incredible knowledge and power. Todays interview is with robin collins, professor of philosophy at messiah college. It seems to me that the question of why we should single out intelligent life as an instance of design from finetuning may be less important for some versions of the teleological argument than for others. As ive said before, i dont look to christopher hitchens if i want to hear the most sophisticated arguments for or against god, but he did have a snappy comeback in a debate about the apparent fine tuning of the universe with rabbi wolpe years ago. First, it points out a crucial difference between the standard argument from finetuning for the multiverse and. One prominent champion of the finetuning argument for gods existence is richard swinburne swinburne 1991. Finetuning the argument from finetuning objections final evaluation core assumption. Finetuning argument for god imagine that the room is wired to explode unless some dials outside of room are set to the right combination. Finetuning, complexity, and life in the multiverse arxiv. It takes off from something that serious physicists, religious or not, tend to agree on. However, the idea that the universe is all is not a scientific fact, but an assumption based upon materialistic naturalism.
Second, the paper develops a new finetuning argument for the multiverse which, unlike the old one, parallels the structure of paradigmatic instances of anthropic reasoning. The question of whether probabilities either do not apply or have been improperly applied to cosmological finetuning continues to draw. The finetuning argument, to be abbreviated by fta in what follows, claims that the present universe including the laws that govern it and the initial conditions from which it has evolved permits life only because these laws and conditions take a very special form, small changes in which would make. Let me restate the fine tuning argument so its clear what we are talking about from wikipedia. Nature of project and summary of sections historically, the argument from design probably has been the most widely cited argument. Science provides us with a sense of wonder about this vast universe. First, if the initial conditions prevailing immediately after the big bang had been ever so slightly di erent, then the universe would either have recollapsed immediately, or. Fine tuning says that there are target levels that have to be hit exactly right in order for life to develop in a universe and hitting each one of them is so vastly improbable that the odds indicate some. Contemporary cosmological design arguments fall broadly under two headings. A scientific argument for the existence of god, he mentions that one of the objections that challenges the core version of finetuning argument is the who designed god objection. Finetuning is not surprising analysis oxford academic. His training is in physics and in philosophy and he is a leading advocate for using the fine tuning of the universe as a design argument for theism. Evidence for the fine tuning of the universe by rich deem introduction.
The argument for fine tuning can thus be recast such that almost all values of c are outside of the lifepermitting range. How to rigorously define finetuning by robin collins, note. The fine tuning argument poses what seems to be another tough obstacle for the atheist. And if one is not already convinced about the existence of a designer, but thinks that it is a coherent possibility, one may be tempted to regard finetuning as reason for increasing ones credence in that hypothesis. Hitchens on the fine tuning argument as ive said before, i dont look to christopher hitchens if i want to hear the most sophisticated arguments for or against god, but he did have a snappy comeback in a debate about the apparent fine tuning of the universe with rabbi wolpe years ago. What i pointed out is that there is most likely no tuning at all since the universe is vastly fatal to us. The question of whether probabilities either do not apply or have been improperly applied to cosmological fine tuning continues to draw.
Robin collins finetuning argument robin collins is the distinguished professor of philosophy at messiah college in grantham, pa. Likewise, if our universe is selected from a multiverse, its seemingly designed or finetuned features wouldnt be surprising. The fine tuning argument klaas landsman april 5, 2015 abstract our laws of nature and our cosmos appear to be delicately netuned for life to emerge. The netuning of the universe for intelligent life has received much attention in recent times. However, recent supernova 1a data demonstrated the. The first objection is that fine tuning can be explained in terms of. He has done some extensive work on the finetuning of the universe and why the features we see point to the existence of god. How do atheists respond to the fine tuning argument. The fine tuning argument is one of the most common creationist arguments. The ne tuning of the universe for intelligent life has received much attention in recent times. Introduction1 the evidence of finetuning suppose we went on a mission to mars, and found a domed structure in which everything was set up just right for life to exist. I think the multiverse supporter can grant this and argue that the prior probability of a multiverse is not too small. First hypothesized by albert einstein, the cosmological constant was rejected by him, because of lack of real world data. But the argument does allege to provide powerful evidence for theism.
Teleological arguments for gods existence stanford. Just to give an idea of the enormity of some of the numbers we are about to toss around below, lets look at a few examples. Pdf finetuning, cosmic hostility, and the argument from. The fact that our universe is lifepermitting is therefore in need of explanation. For instance, some of them have taken the beginning of the universe in a big bang to be evidence that god created it ex nihilo. The fact that the room didnt explode should make you more con. Mar 24, 2014 i will present a probabilistic version of this fine tuning argument which is stronger than all other versions in the literature. One reaction to these apparent enormous coincidences is to see them as substantiating the theistic claim that the universe has been created by a personal god and as offering the material for a properly restrained theistic argumenthence the finetuning argument. We will formulate the finetuning argument against the atheistic single universe hypothesis is in terms of what i will call the prime principle of confirmation. Life or the formation of stars, depending on the source presupposes a narrow range of physical constant, and any universe with alternate constants does not support life.
What i am calling the standard finetuning argument is an argument that finetuning, i. Fine tuning and physical necessity fine tuning argument design from fine tuning probability of fine tuning fine tuned universe finely tuned universe is the argument from fine tuning presumptuous. It has occurred to me that my previous formulation of the finetuning argument fta for short could be improved upon. The fine tuned universe is the proposition that the conditions that allo. But as scientists tell us, events that are extremely improbable happen all the time. In this paper the evidence of finetuning is explained and the finetuning design argument for god is. It has occurred to me that my previous formulation of the fine tuning argument fta for short could be improved upon. This argument is legitimate, yet there are numerous doubts about its legitimacy. Oct 01, 2006 what i am calling the standard finetuning argument is an argument that finetuning, i. If this is correct, then the finetuning argument is a weak argument for the existence of god. Problems with the argument from fine tuning 327 the central idea of the. God, finetuning, and the problem of old evidence 407.
It seems to me that the question of why we should single out intelligent life as an instance of design from fine tuning may be less important for some versions of the teleological argument than for others. The probability that all the elements in the universe would be as meticulously fine tuned to unfathomable levels that would allow life as we know it, are incomprehensibly small. Finetuning in cosmology 1 a good overview of the case for finetuning can be found in chapter 2 of leslie 1989. Nevertheless, i will show that one can have reasonable opinions such that the fine tuning argument doesnt lead to an increase in ones probability for the existence of god. The finetuning argument is a modern, uptodate version of this argument. For that, wed need to take into account all the other evidence for or against the existence of god. Creationists use the finetuned universe argument as evidence for gods existence.
The argument for finetuning can thus be recast such that almost all values of c are outside of the lifepermitting range. Creationists use the fine tuned universe argument as evidence for gods existence. Fine tuning the argument from fine tuning objections final evaluation core assumption. Its as if there are a large number of dials that have to be tuned to within. Finetuning and multiple universes roger white massachusetts institute of technology i. The finetuning of the universe for intelligent life. The second objection is the normalizability problem the objection that the fine. Perhaps the universe is being held together by a small number of physical laws, or maybe even one. We could elaborate the physics involved, and put the reasoning in the form of bayes theorem. The many problems of the finetuning argument atheism. A new finetuning argument for the multiverse springerlink. The first objection is that finetuning can be explained in terms of the existence of multiple universes the multiverse plus the operation of the anthropic principle.
386 865 1464 168 911 180 606 37 148 646 1638 1280 944 885 530 580 690 59 1616 1008 657 1403 1222 1282 904 95 707 1154 17 1204 1348 1239 676 641 1148